The 3-2-1 Rule and immutable backups
The 3-2-1 Backup Rule: The Gold Standard of Data Protection
The 3-2-1 rule is a simple, time-tested strategy for ensuring your data can be recovered from almost any disaster. It's a foundational principle used by IT professionals and home users alike.
Here’s what each number means:
3: Keep at least THREE copies of your data.
This includes your primary (live) data and at least two backup copies.
Why? If you only have your original and one backup, you have a single point of failure. If something happens to that one backup, you're out of luck. A second backup drastically reduces your risk.
2: Store your backups on TWO different types of media.
"Media" refers to the physical device or storage technology you use.
Examples: An external hard drive (HDD/SSD), a NAS (Network-Attached Storage), cloud storage, or even magnetic tape (for enterprises).
Why? This protects against media-specific failures. If all your backups are on the same type of hard drive, a flaw in that model or a virus that targets that system could wipe them all out. Diversifying your media mitigates this risk.
1: Keep at least ONE backup copy OFFSITE.
This means a copy that is physically separated from your primary location.
The most common modern solution is cloud storage (e.g., Backblaze, AWS, Azure). Historically, this meant taking tapes or drives to a safe deposit box or another office.
Why? This protects against local and regional disasters like fire, flood, theft, or a major power surge that could destroy all the equipment in your home or office.
In a nutshell: The 3-2-1 rule ensures you have multiple copies, on different devices, in different locations, making data loss highly unlikely.
Immutable Backups: The "Write-Once, Read-Many" Vault
An immutable backup is a backup that cannot be altered or deleted by anyone for a predetermined period of time—not even by a system administrator or the backup software itself.
Immutability means "unchangeable." Once the backup is written, it is locked down.
Think of it like a legal document written in permanent ink and stored in a tamper-evident safe. You can look at it (read it), but you cannot change it or throw it away until the retention period expires.
How is this achieved? Modern backup solutions use features of storage systems (like Amazon S3 Object Lock or Azure Blob Storage Immutability Policies) or leverage Linux-based file system attributes to place a legal "hold" or compliance lock on the backup files.
Why are Immutable Backups So Critical? The #1 Threat: Ransomware
The 3-2-1 rule is excellent, but it has a vulnerability: human error and malicious software.
Ransomware Evolution: Modern ransomware doesn't just encrypt your live data. It actively seeks out your connected backups (external drives, NAS) to encrypt or delete them first. This is how they force you to pay the ransom.
The Attack: If a hacker gains access to your system, they could potentially gain access to your backup software and delete all your offsite cloud backups, completely defeating your 3-2-1 strategy.
This is where immutability saves the day. Even if a hacker has your admin credentials, they cannot delete or encrypt an immutable backup. The storage system itself will reject any command to alter the file until the immutability period (e.g., 7, 30, or 90 days) is over. This guarantees you have a "last-known-good" copy to recover from, making ransomware attacks ineffective.
Other benefits of immutability:
Accidental Deletion: Prevents a well-meaning admin from accidentally deleting the wrong backup.
Compliance: Meets strict regulatory requirements for data retention (e.g., SEC, FINRA, HIPAA) by proving data has not been tampered with.
Putting It All Together: The Ultimate Modern Strategy
A robust, modern data protection strategy combines both concepts:
The 3-2-1-1-0 Rule (An Enhanced Standard)
This builds on the 3-2-1 rule by adding:
1: Keep at least one backup copy IMMUTABLE. (This is the crucial addition).
0: Verify your backups to ensure you have ZERO errors. (Automated recovery verification).
Example Scenario for a Business:
Primary Data: Files on the company server.
Backup Copy 1 (On-site, different media): A backup job to a dedicated NAS device.
Backup Copy 2 (Off-site, immutable): A backup job to a cloud provider like Wasabi or Backblaze B2, with Object Lock (immutability) enabled for 30 days.
Backup Copy 3 (Optional, air-gapped): A periodic backup to an external hard drive that is physically disconnected and stored in a safe.
If ransomware infects the network, it may encrypt the primary server and the on-site NAS backup. However, the immutable cloud backup remains untouched and un-deletable. The company can then recover all its data from that cloud copy without paying the ransom.
Summary
3-2-1 Rule
To ensure redundancy and geographic separation of backups.
Protects against hardware failure, local disaster, and accidental loss.
Immutable Backup
To make backups tamper-proof and un-deletable for a set time.
Protects against ransomware, malicious insiders, and accidental deletion.
For any critical data, you should not choose between the 3-2-1 rule and immutability. You should use both to create a defense-in-depth strategy that is resilient against both random accidents and targeted malicious attacks.
Last updated